Scam red flags on every listing, before you message
Quick answer
Sift, a free browser extension for Facebook Marketplace, reads each listing and, when it shows a common scam sign, puts a red chip naming that sign on its photo: a deposit or payment first, contact off the platform, a seller who can’t meet, or a price far below similar listings. Green chips mark good signs. Still unsure? Press Is this a good deal? for an AI second opinion on the listing.
Description
Grey fabric sectional, about two years old. No stains, no pets, smoke-free home. E-transfer $50 to hold it and pay the rest at pickup. Text me at 416-555-0187, I don’t check messages on here.
Things to check
Asks for money before you see it“E-transfer $50 to hold it”
Wants to talk outside the site“416-555-0187”
Check elsewhere
What Sift flags
Sift looks for the four warning signs that Meta, the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre and the FTC all describe in their scam advice. When a listing matches one, a small red chip names the sign on its photo: Pay first, Off-site contact, Seller away, Ships only or Very low price. Sift never calls a listing a scam. It shows you the line that raised the flag, and you decide.
| Red flag | What it looks like | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Payment or deposit first | A request for a deposit to hold the item, or payment by e-Transfer, gift card or wire before you have seen it | Money before you see the item is the heart of most buyer scams, and these methods are hard to reverse |
| Off-platform contact | A push to move the chat to WhatsApp, text or email | It moves the conversation somewhere the site can’t see it |
| Remote seller | A seller who is away, moving or can only ship something you would normally collect | A seller who can’t meet can’t show you the item |
| Far too cheap | A price far below similar listings | Meta warns that underpriced items are used to lure buyers |
Click a chip and the details card tells you why the listing was flagged, so you can judge it yourself. Sift works on French listings too.
Good signs
Not every listing is a worry, and some carry the details careful sellers include. Sift marks those with a green chip, for things like:
- one owner
- service or maintenance records
- a receipt
- the original box
- a clean title or Carfax
- warranty remaining
A green chip doesn’t outweigh a red one. A listing with “service records” and “e-transfer deposit first” is still a listing that wants money before you’ve seen the car.
Extra checks for LEGO, bikes and phones
Shopping for something specific? Sift adds category checks for the item itself, and their chips come first on the card.
- LEGO: red “May not be LEGO brand”, “Incomplete set” and “No minifigures”; green “Complete set”, “Sealed” and “Minifigs included”.
- Bikes: red “No serial number”, “Lock without key” and “Found bike”; green “Serial shown”.
- Phones: red “Activation locked”, “Blacklisted or bad IMEI” and “Still financed”; green “Unlocked”, “Clean IMEI” and “AppleCare”.
How it works
Everything happens in your browser, as the page loads.
- Sift reads each listing. On a search page it checks what each listing shows. Open a listing and Sift checks the full description too, which is where most payment and contact details hide on Facebook.
- It compares the price with similar listings. Cheap ones get a Below typical badge, overpriced ones get Above typical, and a price far below similar listings gets a red Very low price flag. A price in line with similar listings gets no price badge.
- It shows its working. Click any chip and the details card opens: price history, the fair-price verdict, each red flag and why it was raised, good signs, and links to check elsewhere.
What you browse stays on your computer; our privacy page explains it in plain language. Everything else Sift does is on the features page.
What it looks like on a search
Say you search for a sectional within 25 km of home and get 40 results (the listings here are illustrative). Most look ordinary and carry no chip at all. Three stand out:
- A sectional at $150 when similar listings sit around $600 to $900. It gets a red “Very low price” chip. Open the details card and you see the typical price it was compared against.
- A sectional whose description says “I’m out of town, e-transfer $50 to hold it”. It gets “Pay first” and “Seller away”, and the details card quotes the line behind each.
- A sectional listed with “original receipt, one owner”. It gets a green “Receipt” chip and no price badge, because its price is in line with similar listings.
Nothing is hidden. You still see all 40 listings; you just know which three to read more carefully before you write to anyone. If you’d rather not see some kinds of listing at all, Sift’s filters hide them.
A second opinion before you pay
Not sure about a listing that looks almost right? Press Is this a good deal? in Sift’s details card. Sift reads the ad, the asking price and similar listings near you and gives you a verdict in plain words, such as “Be careful with this one”, with the reasons behind it, a fair offer and a message to the seller ready to copy. Free comes with three second opinions a month, and Sift Pro with 50. More on the AI second opinion.
Second opinion
Be careful with this one
The seller wants an e-transfer before you see it.
$90 is far under what similar turntables go for.
Offer to pay in person at pickup, after you’ve tried it.
Keep the usual rules
Scammers adapt, and a careful one can write a perfectly normal listing, then ask for a deposit once you’ve messaged. Sift reads listings, never your chats, so keep the rules that work with or without it: check the seller’s profile (how old it is, ratings, other listings), see the item, keep the chat on the site, and pay at pickup. Our guide to Facebook Marketplace scams has the full checklist, and should you pay a deposit? covers the most common script.
Check the photo and the price elsewhere
From any listing’s details card, one click opens:
- Google Lens on the listing photo, to see whether the pictures were lifted from a shop or an older listing;
- eBay sold prices for the same title, to see what the item really sells for;
- Google Shopping, to compare with the new price;
- the same search on the other site, Kijiji from Facebook or Facebook Marketplace from Kijiji.
They are plain links that open in a new tab, never affiliate-tagged. For a fuller picture of whether the price is right, the price tracker shows every drop Sift has seen on a listing, and our guide to paying safely covers the step after you’ve decided to buy.
Where it works
Sift works on Facebook Marketplace and on Kijiji once you switch on Kijiji in Sift, in Chrome, Edge and Brave on a computer, and it runs alongside everything else Sift does: hiding sponsored and sold listings, price drops, new-listing alerts, a real distance radius, an AI second opinion on any listing and a VIN check on car ads. With Sift Pro, alerts for your watched searches go to your phone. It’s free, and there’s no account.
Sift is not affiliated with Meta, Facebook or Kijiji.
Questions people ask
Can Sift tell me if a seller is a scammer?
Sift points out the warning signs in a listing, such as a deposit request, a WhatsApp number or a price far below similar items, and shows you why it flagged each one. For a second look, press “Is this a good deal?” and Sift’s AI second opinion tells you “Looks like a good deal” or “Be careful with this one”, with the reasons. Then meet, inspect and pay.
Does Sift read my messages?
No. Sift reads listings only, the cards in your search results and the listing page you open. It never opens, reads or sends Messenger or Kijiji messages.
Does the scam check work on Kijiji?
Yes. Switch on Kijiji in Sift and the same red flags and good signs work there, and Sift understands French listings too, which matters for Kijiji in Quebec. From any listing you can also run the same search on the other site in one click.
Does Sift send listing data anywhere?
Only when you ask it to. The scam check runs in your browser, and your browsing and listing history stay on your computer. Sift’s server only handles what you ask it to: your plan, phone alerts, second opinions and VIN checks. Links to other sites, such as Google Lens, open only when you click them. Our privacy page has the plain-language details.
Is the scam check free?
Yes. The red flags are free on every listing, with no account to create, and Free includes three AI second opinions a month, 50 with Sift Pro. Sift runs in Chrome, Edge and Brave on a computer.
Sources
- 01Meta Help Centre About scams on Facebook Marketplace
- 02Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre Check twice, pay once (October 2025)
- 03Federal Trade Commission Buying from an online marketplace