Buying guides

What to buy used, what never to buy used, and how to check everything in between

Written by
the Sift team
Updated
Reading time
8 min read

Quick answer

The best things to buy used are durable goods that lose value fast and can be checked in person: furniture, bikes, tools, LEGO® sets, consoles, appliances and many electronics. Think twice about anything whose safety history you can’t confirm (car seats, helmets), products Canada bans from resale (baby walkers, drop-side cribs), and anything with a lock, a lien or a serial you can’t check.

Most of what people need is cheaper used, and plenty of it is better made than what replaced it. The trick is knowing which items hide their problems and which don’t. A dresser shows you everything in five minutes. A car seat, a locked phone or a bike with a scratched-off serial can look perfect and still be the wrong buy. These guides cover one kind of item each: where to find the good ones on Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji, what a fair price looks like, the scams that come with that category, and what to check before you pay.

Good to buy used, with the right checks

These are the categories where buying used makes the most sense, as long as you do the one check that matters for each.

Good to buy used, and the check that matters most
CategoryWhy buying used makes senseThe check that matters mostGuide
Pokémon and other trading cardsCards trade at prices tracked from completed sales, so you can price almost anythingThe price against completed sales, not other people’s asking pricesPokémon cards
LEGO® setsBricks don’t wear out, and retired sets are only available usedThe set number, and whether it is complete with its minifiguresUsed LEGO sets
Bikes and e-bikesA good frame lasts for years; the first owner absorbs the drop in valueThe serial number (is it stolen?) and the frame sizeUsed bikes
Phones and tabletsLast year’s model costs far less and does nearly everything this year’s doesActivation Lock off, and a clean IMEIUsed iPhones
Cars and trucksA new car loses value fastest in its first yearsA history report, a lien check and an independent inspectionInspection checklist
Motorcycles and powersportsOften lightly used and stored for the winterThe VIN against the paperwork, and the seller’s name on the ownershipMotorcycles
FurnitureResells for a fraction of its price new, and solid wood outlasts flat-packBed bugs, and your measurements before you goFurniture
AppliancesBig, heavy and often sold cheaply by people who are movingSee it running at the seller’s, and check the age on the labelAppliances
Consoles and PC partsHardware outlives its owner’s interest in itTest it, and check it can still go onlineConsoles, GPUs and PCs
Baby gearUsed for months, then outgrownExpiry dates, recalls and what Canada bans from resaleBaby gear

Think twice before buying these used

None of this is about fear. These are the items where the risk is something you can’t see, or where the sale itself is illegal in Canada.

Items to skip or check with extra care
ItemWhyWhat the rule says
Baby walkersBanned in Canada since April 2004, including second-hand salesHealth Canada lists them among products that cannot be sold, advertised or given away
Traditional drop-side cribsHardware failures can trap a babyTheir sale, new or used, has been prohibited since December 29, 2016
Inclined infant sleep productsSuffocation riskListed by Health Canada as banned products
Car seats with an unknown historyA seat that has been in a crash may not protect a child, even with no visible damageHealth Canada: don’t buy one if the seller doesn’t know its history. Transport Canada: seats made before January 1, 2012 may be illegal to advertise, sell or give away
Bike, ski and other single-impact helmetsOne hit can use up their protection, and you can’t see itHealth Canada advises against buying single-impact helmets second-hand
Mattresses and upholstered bedsBed bugs hide in seams and are easy to missHealth Canada says to check any second-hand furniture or bedding yourself and not to rely on the seller’s word
Phones that are “iCloud locked” or “still financed”An Activation Lock means only the previous owner’s Apple Account can set the phone up, and a phone still being paid off has a balance owing on someone else’s planApple: a locked device can’t be used until the owner removes it from their account
Cars without the seller’s name on the ownershipThe classic sign of a curbsider, or a car the seller has no right to sellIn Ontario, a private seller must give you a Used Vehicle Information Package, which shows registered liens

For car seats, cribs, strollers and other children’s products, the full checklist and the block words that keep these listings out of your searches are in buying used baby gear in Canada. For cars, start with stolen-car and VIN checks in Canada and curbsiders.

Guides by category

Each guide below covers one kind of item: searches that find the good listings, the fair price and where to check it, the scams that target that category, and a checklist for the meetup.

0110 pages

Pokémon and trading cards

Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece, Lorcana and sports cards: prices, fakes, sealed product, lots and graded slabs.

025 pages

034 pages

046 pages

058 pages

066 pages

The four checks that apply to everything

Every guide above adds its own checks, but these four apply to anything you buy from a stranger.

  1. Price it against completed sales, not asking prices. An asking price is a hope. What things actually sold for is the real market. Search eBay sold listings, use the price guide for the category (PriceCharting for cards and games, BrickLink for LEGO sets) and compare the same item on both Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji. How to tell if a price is fair goes through it step by step.
  2. Identify the exact item. Get the number that pins it down: a set number for LEGO, a card number and set for Pokémon, a serial for a bike, an IMEI for a phone, a model and serial for an appliance, a VIN for a car. With it you can price the item exactly and check it against the registries that exist.
  3. Inspect it before you pay, in person. See it working, in daylight, in a public place where possible. For big items, go with someone. Bring what you need to test it: a charger, a game disc, a flashlight for furniture seams.
  4. Pay in person, never a deposit. Pay when the item is in your hands. A seller who wants a deposit, an e-transfer “to hold it” or a payment through a link is following the script of the most common Marketplace scam. Read the deposit scam and the safest ways to pay.

Where each category lives on Facebook and Kijiji

Both sites have category pages for these items. Searching inside the category cuts out the noise that a plain keyword search pulls in, such as phone cases in a phone search or LEGO storage bins in a LEGO search.

Category pages on each site
What you wantFacebook MarketplaceKijiji
Cars and trucksVehicles, plus the cars and trucks pagesCars & Trucks, Classic Cars
Bikes and e-bikesBicycles, with mountain, road, gravel, hybrid, BMX, electric and kids’ bike pagesBikes, with BMX, Kids, Mountain, Road, eBike and Cruiser, Commuter & Hybrid
PhonesCell phones, with iPhones, unlocked phones and Google Pixel pagesCell Phones
LEGO setsToys & Games, with LEGO, LEGO DUPLO and building toys pagesToys & Games
Trading cardsAntiques & Collectibles, with trading cards, Pokémon cards and sports trading cards pagesArts & Collectibles, and Toys & Games
Free itemsThe free stuff category, or a price filter of 0Free Stuff

Hunt kits: the category checks Sift adds on a computer

Sift is a free browser extension for Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji. Alongside its general filters, it has hunt kits: extra checks for the things people hunt for most. A kit switches on when Sift recognises what a listing is, and its checks only fire inside that category, so the word “locked” on a dresser never sets off a phone warning. Full details are on the hunt kits page.

Trading cards. Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece, Lorcana and graded titles get one-click links to the card’s prices on PriceCharting and TCGplayer, with grade and condition words stripped from the search so it finds the card. The Cards hunt hides “PM for price” posts, which tell you nothing.

LEGO. Sift reads the set number from the title (“LEGO · set 75192”) and links straight to BrickLink’s price guide for that set. It marks wording that says a listing may not be LEGO brand, an incomplete set or missing minifigures, and good signs such as sealed, complete and instructions included.

Bikes. Sift reads the frame size, lets you hide every size but yours, and links a written serial to Bike Index, or searches Bike Index for stolen bikes reported near the listing’s city. Wording such as “no serial”, “lost the lock key” or “found this bike” gets a Check this chip.

Phones and devices. “iCloud locked”, “blacklisted” and “still financed” get Check this chips; “unlocked”, “clean IMEI” and AppleCare get green ones. Phones, tablets and watches link to a free IMEI check.

Cars. The Car hunt sets year and maximum-mileage limits, hides salvage, rebuilt, flood, as-is and for-parts titles, hides dealers and dims cars you have already looked at.

In Sift’s options, Start a hunt sets up any of these in one click and saves it as a preset you can switch to from the popup. Sift does not authenticate cards, sets or devices, and it doesn’t check registries itself: it reads what the seller wrote and takes you to the right place to check. It runs on Chrome, Edge and Brave on a computer, not on phones.

Trademarks

LEGO® is a trademark of the LEGO Group of companies, which does not sponsor, authorize or endorse this site. Pokémon is a trademark of Nintendo, Creatures Inc., GAME FREAK inc. and The Pokémon Company, none of which is affiliated with Sift. Sift is independent and not affiliated with Meta, Facebook, Kijiji or any brand named in these guides.

Questions people ask

What are the best things to buy used?

Things that lose value quickly but last for years and can be checked in person. Furniture, bikes, tools, LEGO sets, consoles, many appliances and most electronics are good examples. Check the price against completed sales, see the item working, and pay when you have it in your hands.

What should you never buy used?

Anything whose safety history you can’t verify, such as a car seat with an unknown history or a helmet that may have taken a hit, plus products Canada bans from resale, such as baby walkers, traditional drop-side cribs and inclined infant sleep products. Be careful with mattresses too, because of bed bugs.

Is it safe to buy used electronics on Facebook Marketplace?

Yes, with checks. See the item working, check locks and serials (Activation Lock and the IMEI for phones, online sign-in for consoles), meet in a busy public place and pay in person once you have tested it. Never send a deposit to hold an item.

What is a hunt kit in Sift?

A set of checks Sift adds for one kind of item on Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji, such as PriceCharting links for trading cards, BrickLink’s price guide for LEGO sets or Bike Index links for bikes. It switches on by itself when Sift recognises the item.

Sources

  1. 01Health Canada Buying second-hand products
  2. 02Health Canada Information for shoppers of second-hand products
  3. 03Government of Canada Minister Pettigrew announces a ban on baby walkers (April 2004)
  4. 04Transport Canada Expiry dates on child car seats and booster seats
  5. 05Health Canada Second-hand car seat and booster seat safety
  6. 06Health Canada Bedbugs: how do I prevent an infestation
  7. 07Apple Support Activation Lock for iPhone and iPad
  8. 08Ontario.ca Used Vehicle Information Package
  9. 09The LEGO Group Fair Play (trademark guidelines)
  10. 10The Pokémon Company International Legal information