What to check when buying a used car privately: the printable checklist
Quick answer
Check a used car in four passes: listing, title and history, condition, then an independent mechanical inspection. In the US, use your state motor vehicle agency for title, lien and transfer requirements, an appropriate vehicle history check and NHTSA for recalls. Match the VIN to the actual vehicle and documents. Canadian buyers have separate provincial checks below. Complete essential checks before payment.
| Pass | What you are checking | When |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The listing | Year, mileage, trim, title status, who is selling | Before you message |
| 2. Paperwork and history | Ownership, VIN, liens, stolen check, recalls, vehicle history | Before you drive over |
| 3. The car | Cold start, walk-around, underneath, interior, test drive | At the viewing, in daylight |
| 4. A mechanic | Pre-purchase inspection on a hoist | Before you pay anything |
The early passes can uncover inconsistencies before a trip. A walk-around and short drive have limits; a history check does not replace the independent mechanical inspection.
What you get, and don’t get, in a private sale
A private purchase has a different contract and protection framework from a dealer purchase. Do not assume a return period, warranty or dealer protection applies. Obtain the actual terms in writing and check the applicable state or provincial rules.
United States: title and transfer first
Find your state motor vehicle agency through USAGov. Confirm the seller’s authority, the original title or permitted substitute, lien release, required signatures, taxes, registration and any inspection or temporary-permit requirements for your situation. A bill of sale alone may not be sufficient. Interstate purchases need the rules for both the sale and destination checked.
Use an NMVTIS report from an approved provider as one history source. NICB VINCheck is a limited additional theft/salvage check involving participating insurers; a clear result is not proof of a clean vehicle. Neither replaces the title process, a lien check or an independent inspection.
Canada: provincial documents
Canadian paperwork differs by province. These are starting points for Canadian buyers, not requirements for US transactions:
| Province | What the seller gives you | Liens | Status and history |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario | The Used Vehicle Information Package (UVIP, $20 from ServiceOntario), a signed ownership and a bill of sale | Listed in the UVIP | UVIP shows past owners, their odometer readings and whether the car was branded; you need a Safety Standards Certificate to plate it |
| British Columbia | The registration and a transfer form | Personal Property Registry search, or the lien search in a CARFAX Canada report | Free online status check (normal, rebuilt, salvage, altered or non-repairable) |
| Quebec | The registration certificate | RDPRM search (there is a fee) | Vehicle history through SAAQclic |
| Alberta | The registration and a bill of sale | Vehicle Information Report shows liens | Same report; AMVIC’s licence lookup if the seller seems to be a business |
For Ontario, confirm the current deadlines, tax rules and applicable exemptions in the provincial buying guide. Canadian buyers can also use buying a used car on Kijiji for provincial starting points.
Pass 1: read the listing before you message
The listing tells you what to ask and sometimes tells you to move on.
- Year, mileage and trim. A listing with no mileage is hiding something or was written in a hurry. Ask before you go.
- Title status. Look for “rebuilt”, “salvage”, “as-is”, “needs safety”, “for parts” and, in Quebec, “VGA”, “reconstruit” or “irrécupérable”. Often it is the last line of the description. Our rebuilt and salvage guide for Canada covers Canadian examples. US buyers should establish the recorded brand and restrictions with the relevant state agency.
- Photos. Good sellers photograph the odometer, the tires and the rust they know about. Ask about photos that crop out the lower doors and rockers.
- Who is selling. Several cars on one profile, financing wording (“OAC”, “we finance”, “$500 down”), a stock number or “plus tax and licensing” mean a dealer, or a curbsider posing as a private seller.
- The price. Far under similar cars nearby means there is a reason. Find it before you drive.
Is the price fair?
Build a local comparison using the same model, close model years, similar mileage, trim, condition and recorded title status. Marketplace asking prices are not confirmed sold prices. Long listing age is context, not proof that a seller will accept less. Include immediate maintenance and transfer costs. Canadian buyers may also compare Kijiji listings. Our guide to judging a fair price explains how to keep package differences visible.
Finding the good ones first
Clean, fairly priced private-sale cars don’t sit for long. Sort by newest, search a few times a day, and check the older listings too: a car that has sat for three weeks is one where the seller is ready to talk. When a search returns a car, check the other site for the same car; sellers often post on both at different prices.
Questions to ask the seller
Copy these into your first message. Specific questions get specific answers, and vague answers to specific questions tell you something.
- What is the VIN?
- Is the ownership in your name, and is any money owed on the car?
- Has it been in an accident or had an insurance claim? Is the title branded?
- What service records do you have? When were the brakes, tires and timing belt (if it has one) last done?
- Why are you selling?
- Does it come with winter tires? Has it been rust-proofed?
- What inspection or emissions documents are required here, and are they available?
- Can I take it to my mechanic for a pre-purchase inspection?
- Can you leave it cold, not started, before I arrive?
Pass 2: paperwork and history checks
- Get the VIN before you go. Match it to the vehicle and documents at the viewing; a typed number alone does not identify the car.
- Check available theft and title records. In the US, use the relevant state process, an appropriate NMVTIS provider and NICB’s limited lookup. In Canada, use the Canadian VIN workflow, including CPIC. Resolve any discrepancy before proceeding.
- Check liens and release requirements. Establish the applicable official process and any lender’s documented release instructions. Do not rely on a seller’s promise to pay a balance later.
- Review history. Compare reported damage, ownership/registration records and odometer readings with the seller’s account. Missing reports do not prove that damage never occurred.
- Check recalls. In the US, use NHTSA’s VIN lookup and the manufacturer; Canadian buyers should use Transport Canada. A clear VIN result is not a full recall history: repaired recalls, some recent campaigns and older recalls may be absent. Confirm with the manufacturer. Follow current stop-driving or remedy directions and establish the plan before purchase. When the ad shows the VIN, Sift’s VIN check puts the recalls on record for that model right on the listing.
- Get an insurance quote. Confirm that the identified vehicle and any recorded brand can be insured for your intended use.
Pass 3: the walk-around
Go in daylight, on a dry day if you can. Bring a flashlight, a magnet, paper towel and a friend.
Outside
- Panel gaps that differ side to side, paint that doesn’t quite match, overspray on rubber seals: signs of bodywork. Ask about it.
- Rust on the rocker panels, wheel arches, door bottoms, tailgate and hood edge. Bubbling paint is rust coming through.
- Tires: even wear across the tread, matching brands, and the four-digit date code on the sidewall (week and year). Uneven wear points to alignment or suspension problems.
- Glass: chips and cracks in the windshield. Lights: every one, including the brake lights (your friend helps).
Under the hood, engine cold
- Oil level and colour on the dipstick. Milky residue under the oil cap can mean a head gasket problem, or just a car used for short winter trips.
- Coolant level and colour. Leaks or crusty residue around hoses.
- Fresh engine washing on an older car can hide leaks.
Underneath
- Frame or subframe, brake and fuel lines, the exhaust and the floor pans. In regions where road salt is used, surface rust is normal. Rot, flaking metal and holes are not.
- Drips under the engine and transmission, and wet spots on the driveway where it was parked.
Inside
- Warning lights should come on at start-up, then go out. One that never lights up may have been disconnected.
- A musty smell, damp carpets, silt under the floor mats or in the spare-tire well: flood signs.
- Wear on the pedals, steering wheel and driver’s seat that matches the recorded mileage. Heavy wear on a low-mileage car is a reason to read how to check for odometer rollback.
- Every window, lock, seat adjustment, the heat, the air conditioning and the rear defroster.
The test drive
- Cold start. Knocks, rattles, blue or white smoke, or a rough idle that smooths out once warm.
- City. Smooth shifts up and down, no clunks over bumps, no pulling under braking.
- Highway. No vibration at speed, straight tracking with a light hand on the wheel, quiet wheel bearings.
- Parking lot. Full lock both ways, listening for clicks from the CV joints.
- After. Look under the car again for new drips, and check that no warning light came on.
Pass 4: the pre-purchase inspection
A mechanic you choose, with the car on a hoist, sees the frame, suspension, brake lines and leaks properly, and can scan the computer for stored fault codes. Expect to pay for an hour or so of shop time; it is still the cheapest money in the deal. Book it at a shop near the seller if that helps them agree. A seller who refuses an inspection by a mechanic of your choice is on OMVIC’s list of curbsider signs. Whatever the reason, walk.
Use the results to negotiate. Brakes due, two tires to replace, a leaking gasket: each is a number you can put to the seller. More in how to negotiate on Marketplace.
Paying and transferring
- Never pay a deposit to hold a car you haven’t seen. Kijiji’s own advice: “Never send a deposit before inspecting the vehicle.” This is the most common way car buyers lose money; see the deposit scam.
- Agree the payment sequence with your financial institution. A branch meeting may help coordinate payment and documents, but a cashier’s check, draft or transfer should not be accepted solely on appearance or a screenshot. Confirm verification and the handover sequence in advance.
- Get a bill of sale with the date, price, VIN, make, model, year, both names and addresses, and both signatures.
- Complete the required title or ownership transfer through the relevant state or provincial process. Arrange insurance and any required permit or registration before driving; keep your copies of the sale documents.
The one-page checklist
Print this page, or save it to your phone, and tick it off at the viewing.
| Step | Check | Done |
|---|---|---|
| Listing | Year, mileage, trim and title status stated; seller looks private | ☐ |
| Questions | VIN, accidents, ownership and liens, records, inspection allowed | ☐ |
| VIN | Decoded; matches the ad; same on dash, door jamb and ownership | ☐ |
| Stolen | Appropriate theft checks reviewed; coverage limits understood | ☐ |
| Liens | Relevant lien/title search and any lender release resolved | ☐ |
| History | Vehicle history reviewed; odometer readings and units reconciled | ☐ |
| Recalls | NHTSA or local authority plus maker checked; recall plan established | ☐ |
| Seller | Name on the ownership matches their ID | ☐ |
| Outside | Gaps, paint, rust, tires and date codes, glass, lights | ☐ |
| Engine | Cold start, oil, coolant, leaks, smoke | ☐ |
| Underneath | Frame, brake and fuel lines, floor pans | ☐ |
| Inside | Warning lights, flood signs, wear considered alongside mileage, every switch | ☐ |
| Drive | Shifts, brakes, steering, highway, full lock | ☐ |
| Mechanic | Pre-purchase inspection done; findings priced | ☐ |
| Payment | At a bank, at handover; bill of sale signed | ☐ |
Before the meetup, with Sift
Pass 1 is where most time goes: scrolling past dealer stock, rebuilt titles and cars you already ruled out. Sift, a free browser extension for Facebook Marketplace, does that pass on a computer. One click sets Sift up for a car search: it asks for the model years and maximum mileage you want, hides branded titles and dealers, and dims listings you’ve already seen.
- Year range and maximum mileage, so you only see cars that fit.
- Branded titles hidden: salvage, rebuilt, flood, as-is and for parts, in English and French, including Quebec’s VGA, reconstruit and irrécupérable.
- Dealers hidden or tagged “Dealer”, so private sellers stand out.
- Price context: Sift compares each price with similar listings. Cheap cars get a Below typical badge, overpriced ones get Above typical, and a price far below similar listings gets a red Very low price flag. Kijiji’s own price label still shows where it has one, and price-drop badges and each car’s price history show how far a seller has already come down.
- Red warning chips such as Pay first, Off-site contact or Seller away for common warning signs, like a request for a deposit, a push to text off the platform or a seller who says they’re out of town, and green chips for good signs like one owner, service records, a clean Carfax and no accidents.
- VIN check: when the ad shows a VIN, Sift checks it matches the year, make and model in the ad (“Matches the ad”) and shows recalls on record for that model. One check a month is free, and with Sift Pro every car gets one.
- A second opinion: press “Is this a good deal?” for an AI second opinion on the car: a verdict, the reasons, a fair offer and a message to the seller ready to copy.
- Alerts: watch a search in Sift and it lets you know when a new car that passes your filters is listed, on your computer or, with Sift Pro, on your phone.
With pass 1 done and the VIN already matched to the ad, passes 2 to 4 start from a short list: history, lien and stolen checks, the walk-around and the mechanic. Sift runs in Chrome, Edge and Brave on a computer.
Questions people ask
What should I check before buying a used car privately?
Check the seller’s authority, title or local ownership documents, matching VIN, relevant history and liens, recalls, condition and an independent inspection. Confirm the transfer requirements where you buy and register the vehicle before paying.
What questions should I ask a private car seller?
Ask for the VIN, whether it has been in an accident, whether the ownership is in their name and money is owed on it, what service records they have, why they are selling, and whether you can take it to a mechanic. Ask for the VIN before you drive over.
Should I get a used car inspected before buying?
Yes. A pre-purchase inspection costs far less than most of the problems it finds, and it gives you facts to negotiate with. A seller who refuses one is a reason to walk away.
Does Sift check the car’s VIN?
Yes. When the ad shows the VIN, Sift checks that it matches the year, make and model in the ad and shows recalls on record for that model. It also filters listings by year, mileage and title status, tags dealers and flags risky wording before you go, so you spend the lien and stolen checks on cars worth seeing.
Sources
- 01USAGov State motor vehicle services
- 02US Department of Justice Understanding an NMVTIS report
- 03NICB VINCheck
- 04NHTSA Recalls
- 05FTC Buying a used car from a dealer
- 06Ontario.ca Used Vehicle Information Package
- 07Ontario.ca Buy or sell a used vehicle in Ontario
- 08Vehicle Sales Authority of BC Private buying tips
- 09Office de la protection du consommateur (Quebec) Buying a used car from a private seller
- 10Government of Alberta Vehicle information report
- 11OMVIC Curbsiders
- 12Canadian Police Information Centre Search vehicles
- 13Transport Canada Motor Vehicle Safety Recalls Database
- 14Kijiji Help Centre Avoiding vehicle scams
- 15Kijiji Help Centre Kijiji price analysis