How to negotiate on Facebook Marketplace without getting ignored

Quick answer

Identify the item, research a fair range and set your maximum complete cost before messaging. Ask a specific unanswered question, offer a price supported by the condition or comparable evidence, and suggest a collection time you can keep. Respect a firm price and make any purchase commitment conditional on the agreed inspection.

First messages that get replies

A useful first message shows what you need to know and what you can realistically do next. No script guarantees a response. Adapt these illustrative messages to the item and avoid claiming research you have not done.

1. A question and a time

Hi, does the chair’s height adjustment stay in position when someone sits in it? If so, I could view it Saturday morning.

Use this when you need one important answer before arranging the inspection. Check that the listing has not already answered the question.

2. An offer with a reason

I’m interested in the monitor. I would need to buy the missing stand. Would you consider $140, subject to checking the screen and ports?

Use a real replacement cost and a researched budget. A clear condition on the offer avoids implying that you will buy an item regardless of what the test shows.

3. A bundle

Would you consider $200 for the table and four chairs together? I can bring suitable transport and collect Sunday afternoon.

Confirm exactly which items are included and whether the collection plan works. Do not assume a bundle must receive a discount.

4. Cash and today

I could collect after 5 today if that suits you. Would $80 work, after I check that it matches the description? We can confirm the payment method beforehand.

A reliable collection plan may be useful, but urgency does not make a payment method automatically safe. Only offer a time you can keep.

5. A car

I’m interested in the car. Are service records available, and is there any finance owing? I would like to arrange an independent inspection before making a final commitment.

For a vehicle, establish the history, ownership and mechanical condition. OMVIC recommends an independent inspection and identifies resistance to it as a warning sign.

Why “Is this still available?” gets ignored

A short availability question gives the seller little information about what should happen next. Add a specific question or collection window so they can respond usefully.

Do not assume silence means your offer was insulting or that the seller is dishonest. They may be busy, considering another buyer or no longer selling. A polite follow-up is reasonable; repeated pressure is not helpful.

How much to offer

Use comparable-price research before choosing a number. eBay’s pricing guidance describes using similar and completed listings, but the comparisons still need to match condition and contents.

Set a maximum complete cost, then deduct the collection expenses and required parts. Keep uncertain repairs separate until you understand them. A cheap item with an unexplained fault may not support a sensible offer at all.

For an illustrative stand mixer, suppose equivalent complete candidates are around $150 and a necessary compatible bowl would cost you $35. That missing bowl matters to your budget, but it does not establish a universal $35 discount from any seller’s ask. Use the stand-mixer inspection guide to check the actual machine and attachments.

Choose an offer you can follow through on if the item meets the agreed description. If a counteroffer exceeds your ceiling, decline politely rather than stretching the budget because the conversation has begun.

Bargaining points that are real

Confirmed missing parts, visible wear, documented repair costs and comparable prices can support an offer. A flexible pickup arrangement can also be useful when it genuinely helps both parties.

Listing age, a reduction or an apparent repost provides context but does not prove desperation or predict another discount. The seller may have changed the bundle, paused the sale or listed another similar item.

Record only the price changes you actually observed. Our price-history guide explains why the record is incomplete and why the current contents matter.

Marketplace etiquette

Respect a clearly stated firm price. Ask before changing the agreed collection time. If you decide to pass, say so promptly rather than leaving the seller waiting.

Do not claim faults you have not found or invent competing offers. At pickup, inspect the item as agreed. If a material discrepancy appears, explain it plainly and either discuss a revised price or walk away.

Confirm the payment method and amount before handover. A request for an unverified deposit is a separate risk decision, not a normal requirement for every negotiation. See the deposit-scam guide.

Negotiating on a car

Build the offer around the actual vehicle, its history and the independent inspection. Ask for estimates on significant necessary work rather than assigning arbitrary deductions.

A repair quote does not automatically mean subtracting every dollar from a guide value. Compare with cars in equivalent condition and understand whether maintenance was already reflected in the asking price.

Use the used-car buying guide for ownership, lien, payment and transfer checks. Do not let agreement on price hurry those steps.

Bring the receipts

Keep a concise record of the exact model, comparable evidence, observed asking prices and confirmed extra costs. Share the relevant reasoning politely if it helps explain your offer; avoid publishing personal seller information.

Sift’s price tracker marks price drops on the photo and keeps each listing’s price history. Press “Is this a good deal?” and Sift’s AI second opinion does the homework: a verdict, the reasons, a fair offer (“Offer $600, asking $650”) and a polite message to the seller ready to copy. Pair that with an inspection and a realistic collection plan. The aim is an agreement that makes sense for both parties, not proof that one person has won the exchange.

Questions people ask

Is it rude to negotiate on Marketplace?

A polite offer can be reasonable when the seller is open to offers. Respect a stated firm price, avoid repeated pressure and accept that the seller may decline.

How far below asking should I offer?

There is no universal percentage. Compare equivalent items and subtract confirmed costs you will incur. Offer an amount you would actually pay if the item meets the agreed description. On a computer, press “Is this a good deal?” in Sift for a fair offer on that exact listing, with the reasons behind it.

Should I ask whether it is still available?

You can, but add a relevant question or realistic collection window. That makes the message useful without assuming any particular platform shortcut or guaranteeing a reply.

Can I renegotiate at pickup?

If the item differs materially from the agreement, explain the specific problem and ask whether the price can change, or decline the purchase. Do not invent faults or spring a lower offer simply because the seller has waited for you.

Sources

  1. 01eBay Pricing your items
  2. 02OMVIC Curbsiders and independent inspection